Incomplete DUI records reporting may allow many repeat offenders in Tennessee to avoid proper punishment, which could leave innocent drivers at risk.…
View Article
When an impaired driver causes a crash, the people injured and their families may wonder whether the business that sold the driver alcohol can also be held responsible. In Tennessee, that question falls under dram shop law. Whether a seller can be held liable depends on the circumstances of the sale and its connection to the crash.
Sadly, these types of stories make headlines all too often in Tennessee—and your family is not immune to the devastating risks.
To understand your options after an alcohol-related accident, it is vital to know how state laws govern these complex situations. Contact us for a breakdown of the specific rules and strict legal standards of dram shop liability in Tennessee.
Under the common law, a bar or restaurant selling alcohol was not liable for injuries sustained by the actions of persons who had become intoxicated on their premises. The law viewed the “cause” of the injury to be the actions of the drunk driver, not the actions of the bar simply serving alcohol to the intoxicated person.
In Tennessee, the Legislature codified the common law rule into a statute under Tennessee Code Annotated § 57-10-101. It reads:
“The general assembly hereby finds and declares that the consumption of any alcoholic beverage or beer rather than the furnishing of any alcoholic beverage or beer is the proximate cause of injuries inflicted upon another by an intoxicated person.”
This means generally that a bar is not liable for the actions of patrons who become intoxicated and cause damage or injury to other people.
However, as with many Tennessee laws, there are exceptions. Two, to be exact, which are described in Tenn. Code Ann. § 57-10-102. The first part of the section notes that no damages may be awarded unless the seller of the alcohol was, beyond a reasonable doubt, the proximate cause of the injury or death.
“Proximate cause” means the legal cause of the harm, which has been defined by the Tennessee Supreme Court as “a three-pronged test.” The person’s conduct must have been a “substantial factor” in bringing about the harm, they cannot have been excused from liability by some “rule or policy”, and the harm must have been foreseeable.
The next part of the section lists the two exceptions:
Start With a Free, No
Obligation Consultation
The Tennessee Legislature has set a high bar for liability that protects most sellers of alcohol. If a lawsuit is brought against a bar or other seller of alcohol, the business is entitled to a 12-person jury and the burden of proof is the same as it is in a criminal case, beyond a reasonable doubt, rather than the typical preponderance of the evidence standard for other civil cases.
In the Luau Louie’s case mentioned above involving the underage drunk driver, the family is claiming the bar sold alcohol to a minor. To win this type of case, they will have to show that the defendant bar or restaurant knew the driver was younger than 21 years old when it sold him the alcohol. It is also necessary to prove that the alcohol the bar sold was the proximate cause of the injury. This means the alcohol purchased at the Hula Hut must be shown to have brought about the intoxication and resulted in the injuries or death, and not some additional alcohol that McMurry may have consumed.
Because Tennessee places a heavy burden of proof on dram shop lawsuits, an injured party cannot rely on vague assumptions. Securing compensation requires concrete documentation that satisfies the narrow exceptions established under state law. A claim requires proof of a qualifying sale and causation, plus either a knowing sale to someone known to be under 21 or a sale to a visibly intoxicated person, together with the required causations:
Given these requirements, it is best to enlist the help of an attorney to prove liability in your dram shop claim.
Get a free case review
today. There’s no fee
unless we win!
57-10-102 explicitly uses the term “sold,” and this is done to exclude non-sellers, i.e., one who is not a liquor store, bar, or restaurant. A host at a party generally has no liability for guests who become intoxicated under the dram shop law. However, this does not eliminate all possibility of a lawsuit against someone who has a party and provides alcoholic drinks to their guests.
The courts have developed a complex and involved test under general negligence standards to determine if a “special relationship” exists between the person furnishing the alcohol and the person intoxicated. However, this relationship would probably be limited to circumstances involving supplying alcohol to a minor.
Based on existing Tennessee case law, it appears that if a social host provides free alcohol to guests, knows that some of the guests are minors and then allow the minors to become intoxicated, they potentially could be held liable for injuries those minors cause, should they attempt to drive after becoming intoxicated.
Beyond the straightforward issue of underage guests, Tennessee courts look closely at the exact circumstances of a gathering to see if a host could be held liable under general negligence laws. Two critical situations could completely strip away a social host’s standard legal protections:
Taking voluntary control over an incapacitated guest creates unique legal responsibilities. If a host actively confiscates a drunk guest’s car keys but later hands them back while that person is still heavily impaired, the host could be held accountable for creating a predictable hazard.
Charging a flat cover charge, selling drink tickets, or running a cash bar at a private party fundamentally changes your legal status. The moment money changes hands for alcohol, a court may classify the host as a commercial vendor rather than a neighbor, completely removing standard social host immunity.
Over $500 Million
Recovered on Behalf
of Our Clients
Filing a lawsuit against a commercial establishment does not replace your legal claim against a drunk driver; instead, it acts as an essential layer of financial protection. Relying solely on an at-fault motorist’s auto insurance policy could leave a family financially devastated if catastrophic medical expenses quickly exceed standard policy maximums.
Targeting a negligent venue’s commercial insurance coverage offers two vital protections for injury victims:
Tennessee motorists frequently carry minimal liability coverage that fails to pay for lifetime trauma or long-term rehabilitation. A bar’s commercial policy provides a significantly larger pool of available compensation to help cover these catastrophic costs.
Dram shop accountability is not limited strictly to auto accidents. Licensed venues could be held equally liable if they over-serve a patron who subsequently commits a physical assault or inflicts severe injury on an innocent bystander.
If you have been injured or a family member has been killed in a drunk driving accident, it is a complex and fact-specific analysis that must be done to ascertain potentially responsible parties. An experienced personal injury attorney can examine the facts of your case and help you determine if compensation is available and the possible sources.
Our dedicated legal team at Gatti, Keltner, Bienvenu & Montesi is ready to evaluate your claim and explain dram shop liability in Tennessee. Reach out to us today to secure a partner who will fight for your financial recovery every step of the way.